|
THE WHITE HOUSE Office of the Press Secretary
| For Immediate Release |
|
May 2, 2000 |
REMARKS BY THE PRESIDENT AND THE FIRST LADY AT THE WHITE
HOUSE CONFERENCE ON TEENAGERS: RAISING RESPONSIBLE AND RESOURCEFUL
YOUTH
The East Room
10:45 A.M. EDT
MRS. CLINTON: Good morning, and please be seated, and welcome to the White
House. We have been looking forward to this conference for nearly a year now
as we have talked with and explored all the ways that we can raise resourceful
and responsible young people. And many people have asked me why a conference
on teenagers. Why make teenagers the focus of a fully day's discussion at the
White House.
Well, I think that as we just saw in the video -- and I want to thank and
applaud the families that participated in that video -- many of us are
concerned about what we can do as parents and as citizens, as employers or
educators, as public officials or community leaders, to give more support to
teenagers and their families.
The President and I speak, of course, with great authority -- (laughter) --
having just graduated from being the parents of a teenager to being the
parents of a 20-year-old and having survived it. But, believe me, this
conference is more than just a trip down memory lane or an exercise in
nostalgia for us. We believe strongly that our young people deserve our very
best efforts.
I want to thank many of the people who are here today who have been part of
putting this conference together, but more than that, for the work that they
have done over so many decades. First, let me thank David and Betty Hamburg
who are here. (Applause.) David and Betty, in many ways, inspired this
conference.
I began working with them more than 20 years ago now, and I can think of no
people who are more dedicated to helping all young people, whether they're in
the forgotten or not forgotten half, whether they are going through great
transitions or turning points in their lives. And I think many of us in this
room owe both David and Betty a great deal of gratitude. I would like to ask
them to stand so we could thank them both. (Applause.)
Also with us today is Congresswoman Stephanie Tubbs Jones and Secretary
Donna Shalala, Deputy Attorney General Eric Holder, Secretary Alexis Herman,
National Service Corps CEO Harris Wofford, the Director of Personnel
Management Janis LaChance, the Deputy Drug Czar Vereen, Annie E. Casey
Foundation, the W.T. Grant Foundation and the YMCA of the USA are all sponsors
and supporters of this conference.
Now, all of us are here because we believe there is no group of Americans
more full of promise or potential. But we also believe there is no group of
Americans more in need of the support, guidance and committed efforts of all
of us than today's teenagers.
Ask any teen -- and I do -- I've been privileged to speak to so many in
sort of personal and informal ways and in more formal settings. Just last week
at a high school town hall in Watkins Glen, New York, where the teens lined up
and asked all kinds of questions. If you ask teens and you listen to teens,
you can hear, directly and indirectly, their voices telling us that growing up
today feels tougher than ever before. I happen to think that's right. I think
it's harder being a teen today than it was, certainly, when I was one so many
years ago.
But I also think that the wonder and hope and exciting choices that
teenagers face in their lives are too often becoming times of great stress,
alienation, and confusion. And that, too, has always been part of the teen
experience, but the environment and context in which that occurs is more
dangerous than ever before.
And if it's tough to be a teenager today, it's probably even tougher to be
a parent. More and more parents are working outside our homes; they're
struggling to do right by their families and their jobs. And I have met so
many mothers and fathers who tell me that they just feel inadequate and
anxious about navigating those teenage years -- more so than they certainly
felt when their kids were younger.
We're all worried about the choices our teenagers make, about how the
best-laid plans for a bright future can disintegrate with a single bad
decision to drink, to try drugs, to drive too fast, to trust the wrong person.
Parents are worried about the movies their children are seeing, the web sites
they're visiting, the music they're listening to. And there's a lot of worry
that all those heart-to-heart talks and those efforts to communicate, which
are sometimes so awkward and difficult, about values and good behavior are
getting drowned out by a popular culture filled with gratuitous sex and
violence.
In our two panels this morning, and in the breakout sessions this
afternoon, we will tackle the challenges facing today's teenagers and their
parents. But it won't just be a session for everyone to share their worries.
More importantly, we're going to be highlighting some of the latest research
about teen years and the innovative ways that Americans can work together to
ensure that every teenager has a safe passage to adulthood.
Three years ago, in this room, we held the first White House Conference on
Early Learning and Childhood Development. We sought to raise awareness about
the critical growth that takes place in the brain during the first three years
of life, and to explore the implications of this knowledge on parenting,
education and child care. In many ways, that conference and today's conference
can be viewed as bookends, because now we're beginning to learn that the brain
goes through yet another, and equally critical, growth spurt during the early
teenage years. Though the research is still preliminary, scientists now
believe that this is the time when all the hard-wiring of the brain takes
place, when a teenager's intellectual, emotional and physical capacities are
developed for a lifetime.
Now, I remember the very wise advice I got from a friend of mine, when my
daughter was very small and she was raising three teenagers. And she said, you
know, the two times in a child's life that seem most similar to me are those
toddler years and the teenage years. It's when we need to give so much more
attention to our children. And now, we didn't know, back when I heard this
advice about 19 or so years ago, that there would be brain research to support
that anecdotal experience that parents had. But I remembered that so often
during the times when our own daughter was growing up -- that even if your
teenager or your preteen doesn't want you following her or him around, in many
ways -- think of that toddler metaphor -- they need you around. And it's hard
for a lot of parents to figure out exactly how to do that.
This research has, therefore, important implications for parents, because
teenagers need the guidance and support of their parents more than ever. It is
still difficult for many of us to remember that teenagers want our attention.
After all, this is the time when the real or the imaginary "keep out" signs
start appearing on closed bedroom doors, when many of our children would
rather spend two hours talking to a friend on the phone than 10 minutes
talking to their mother or father in person. But what we are learning is that
for all their declarations of independence, America's teenagers still want and
need the everyday love, involvement and discipline of their parents.
Today, we are releasing a new poll, commissioned by the YMCA, which found
that parents are still the most important adults in their teenagers' lives.
More than three out of four teens say they still turn to their parents in
times of trouble. In fact, while parents -- and this is so interesting --
while parents list the threat of drugs and alcohol as their top concerns about
their teens, teens, themselves, list education and "not having enough time"
with their parents as their top concern.
So it's time that we respond to these concerns, and many of us have been
struggling with ways to do that. I believe one of the biggest casualties of
modern life has been family time, especially time during meals, when parents
and children can check out of their busy schedules and check in with each
other. Before out daughter left for college, the three of us made it a
priority to share at least one meal together a day.
With our hectic schedules, it wasn't always easily and, occasionally,
wasn't possible. But we sure tried. And when we were able to, that hour or
half-hour in the small kitchen of the private quarters upstairs in the White
House was truly my favorite part of the day, because Bill and I were very
convinced that we wanted to convey to our daughter a simple message, one that
we hoped she would carry away to college: that whenever she does need someone
to talk to or ask for advice, or just wants to say hello, we will be available
and eager to listen.
I also know, though, the experience of hanging around, waiting for a
sighting. (Laughter.) You know, when we were first in Washington, in the first
term, a lot of people -- some of the pundits and others -- would say, well,
the Clintons don't go out, they don't socialize enough, you know, why aren't
they going to Camp David enough. And those are people who had forgotten or
never had a teenager. And when you have one in your home, you want to hang
around with the hope that just maybe they'll deign to say something to you.
Occasionally, that works, but not always. And we hope this conference will
inspire even more parents to stay involved in their teenagers' lives and to
open new lines of communication.
I'm very pleased to announce the National Partnership for Women and
Families, along with the Families and Work Institute, will lead a new campaign
to promote the importance of spending time with your teenagers.
Now, there are some lessons we parents have to learn about this. That is
not the time when you unload every piece of worldly advice you have stored up
for your entire lifetime, it is not the time when you lecture and fill up the
space with all the words that you want to fill. These are things that I've
learned from experience.
It is, instead, a time when you hopefully are there to inspire the
communication that is two-way and principally coming from your teen. The Time
With Teens campaign will challenge parents to take stock of their own lives
and work habits and look for ways to make more time for their children.
It will challenge businesses to offer more flexible work schedules and
policies for parents, and it will challenge churches and synagogues, and
mosques and schools, and health care agencies and all community organizations
to create more opportunities for families to spend time together.
But we have to do more than just raise awareness among parents. We have to
give parents the tools we all need to stay involved in our children's lives.
That's why we're also launching a new White House Task Force on Navigating the
New Media Age. Comprised of members from both the public and private sectors,
this task force will find ways to transform the tools of the media age, namely
the Internet, into tools for parents. The task force will develop two new
Internet portals -- one that will link parents to information and advice on
raising teens, from health and safety to child care and education; and a
second to link teens to a variety of age-appropriate resources on the
Internet.
We also recognize it is more difficult for parents to keep track of what
teens are watching and learning on TV or on their home computer. The YMCA poll
you'll hear about found that six out of 10 teenagers are watching television
without parental supervision, while 45 percent of all teens say they surf the
Internet on their own.
You know, when we only had one TV in the home, and you had to fight with
your parents and your brothers and sisters to figure out which one of the
three stations you were going to watch, it was a lot easier for parents to
supervise what their children were watching. Now we have so many opportunities
for kids to see things without any parental supervision, or even without an
older brother or sister around saying, that's stupid, or how dumb that is,
trying to interject some reality into the world that the media conveys to our
kids.
We also know that the V-chip is now in effect, and I strongly urge parents
-- particularly of young kids, but also of teenagers -- to learn how to
program that V-chip and to use it.
There are several media rating systems in place to help parents determine
the appropriateness of the shows their children watch. But with so many
different systems, parents must hunt for the information needed to decode
these various ratings. That's why we will ask the task force to work with the
entertainment and media industries to create a single web site to help parents
make sense of all the various rating systems, and use them to monitor their
children's interactions with the media. I hope eventually, we will get to a
uniform system of ratings, so that what is used on the video shows, is used on
the movies, is used on the TV, is used across the board.
This is only a temporary step, the web site. But I renew, therefore, my
challenge to the entertainment industry. Let's create a voluntary, uniform
rating system so that all parents can better decide what's appropriate and
what is not appropriate for their children to see.
The challenges before us are great, and the time between childhood and
adulthood, as Bill and I can attest, is all too short. But if there is one
message we hope all Americans will take away from this conference, it is that
each of us has the power to make a difference in every teenager's life. And it
is not just a task for parents. The research and our own experience shows that
oftentimes, it is a teacher or a coach, a minister or an employer, a neighbor
or another relative who can provide the mentoring and the stability that every
young person needs. And sometimes during a rocky period in a teen's life, it
may be somebody outside of a parent who can be turned to with good advice and
suggestions.
So it is not just a conference aimed at teens and their parents, it's
really a conference for our entire country; to be committed; to make what is
biologically a disorienting time for our teens and a time of exploration, a
confusing time -- to make it more of an opportunity and a real journey to
self-discovery; to take a time of peril and turn it into a time of promise.
We have a lot of experts and, certainly, we have teens and parents, as well
-- we're going to be talking about what has worked for them. And it will be a
challenge to us. But when I speak to groups of teenagers, I always start by
telling them how proud I am of the way that they are coping with their lives,
because the great, vast majority of our kids are good kids.
That is not the message that we often receive on the media, where we only
see the stereotypes and the negative depictions. And a lot of these kids are
doing the very best they can. In fact, the flip side of our concern is that
some of them take their lives so seriously and strive for such perfection that
the teen years are a time of even heightened misery and anxiety because they
don't think they're measuring up.
So we have got to do a better job in sending a message to our kids that we
value them, we love them, we care about them, and that's why we want to be as
involved in their lives as possible. So let me now introduce my co-parent --
(laughter) -- and someone who has been deeply committed to the young people of
our country, the President of the United States. (Applause.)
THE PRESIDENT: Thank you very much. Thank you and good morning. I want to
join with Hillary in welcoming you to the White House, and thanking all of you
for coming. I thank the foundations that have helped us. And thank you, David
Hamburg. I still remember when we worked on a report about the developmental
needs of young adolescents back in the late '80s, in which we recommended,
among other things, that there ought to be community service in all of our
schools -- something that we're finally getting around to.
I thank all of those who are here. I see so many people out here in this
audience who have done so much to help our young people, our teenagers, live
better lives. I see one of the founders of the City Year program in Boston. I
see a man who has adopted a huge number of children, along with his wife, and
personally made sure that they got through their teenage years. There are
many, many stories here. I'm grateful to all of you.
I'm very grateful to Secretary Shalala and Secretary Herman, and our
National Service Chairman, Senator Harris Wofford; and Deputy Attorney General
Holder, and Janice LaChance, and all the others who are here from the
administration -- the Deputy Director of our Drug Office, Donald Vereen. And
thank you, Representative Stephanie Tubbs Jones. I thank you all for what you
are doing.
I want to thank the panelists, and those who will come on afterward. And I
think we ought to give one more hand to the families that were in the film,
that walked in with Hillary and me. They did a great job. (Applause.)
You know, we've worked very hard on these family issues for a long time,
and Hillary has done so for 30 years. But the way I see this as President, as
well as a parent, looking ahead to the kind of America we're trying to build
in the new century -- when I became President, we had to worry about whether
everybody who wanted or needed a job could get one. And that was very
important. And the dignity of work is very important to families. It helps to
define the shape of family life in ways that are by and large positive.
I'll never forget once when I was governor, I had a panel of former welfare
recipients that were in the work force, and one of my colleagues asked the
lady from my state, said, well, what's the best thing about having a job. And
she said, the best thing about it is when my boy goes to school and they say,
what does your mama do for a living, he can give an answer.
But, by the same token, we live in a country that's very good at creating
jobs, but is not as good at providing family supports; in which people are
busier and busier and busier; and in which virtually everybody has some
trouble balancing work and family during the period of the child's life. Even
parents who are staying at home have trouble doing it.
And it is a problem that is more severe for single parents and people that
have more than one job or people that have trouble getting around. It's a
problem that's more severe for people that work for very modest incomes. But I
don't think I know any parents who are working who have not had some periods
in their lives when they worried whether they were letting their kids down
because they weren't spending enough time with them; or whether there were too
many forces out there that were kind of undermining that.
And one of the things that I have learned, in ways large and small over an
unfortunately increasingly elderly existence -- (laughter) -- is that
everybody has got a story, everybody. And every child has a spark inside. And
I believe that everyone has a role to play and ought to be given a chance. And
as important as work is -- and I say that coming from a family of workaholics
-- the most important work that society does is still to raise children. And
if that work is done well, the rest of it pretty well takes care of itself.
And so we're here, basically, to do all the things that Hillary said. I
think when a tragedy befalls a child, or a child is involved in a tragedy -- a
school shooting, or this terrible incident at the Washington Zoo -- it throws
it up in large relief. But I think that one of the things we ought to do in
beginning this conference is to take a more balanced view. And I want to be
very brief because I want you to have the maximum amount of time with the
keynote speaker and with the panelists. But I think it's important that we
have a balanced view of what teenage life is like today.
And I asked the Council of Economic Advisors to actually get me a
statistical portrait of teenage America. And here is a brief summary. The good
news is that the teenagers are far healthier, more prosperous, and look
forward to more promising lives than ever before in our history. The economic
rewards of education are at an all-time high. Teens have responded by
completing high school and enrolling college at record rates.
Last year, for the first time in the history of the country, the high
school graduation of African Americans and the white majority was almost
statistically identical. The dropout rate among Hispanic young people is still
too high, but that's largely explained, I think, by the fact that we have
still a very large number of Hispanic children in our schools who are
first-generation immigrants whose first language is not English, and they come
from families that are struggling to make ends meet, and very often they drop
out to go to work still. But we're making progress there, as well.
More teenagers than ever before volunteering to serve through community
service. Many harmful behaviors are actually on the decline, including youth
violence, homicide, suicide, teen pregnancy, and, in the last couple of years,
drug use. That's the good news.
The report also highlights some significant challenges. There are still
significant opportunity gaps between white students and students of color.
Teen smoking, drug use and pregnancy are still far too high. And despite a
marked decline in teen homicide over the past few years, still far too many
communities are scarred by gun violence.
Interestingly enough, statistically the Council of Economic Advisers found
that gun-related teen deaths from deliberate acts and from accidents are
highly correlated with gun ownership and possession rates. In states with
fewer guns in fewer households, there are fewer gun deaths.
Perhaps the most empowering finding in the new report is the extents to
which parents have the opportunity to guide their teenagers properly. Sitting
down to dinner can have an enormously positive impact. The report found that
teenagers who had dinner with -- listen to this: The report found that
teenagers that had dinner with their parents five nights a week are far more
likely to avoid smoking, drinking, violence, suicide and drugs. This holds
true for single-parent, as well as two-parent families, across all income and
racial groups. Now, obviously if that is not possible, and sometimes it's not
possible, then it's really important to find some way to fill that gap, but
it's a stunning statistical finding.
For the past seven years, the First Lady and I have worked with our
administration to try to support parents' efforts to raise healthy, hopeful
and responsible children. I'd also like to acknowledge the invaluable efforts
of Vice President and Mrs. Gore, who have had -- even before he joined me,
they were sponsoring a family conference every year in Tennessee to deal with
these issues. It's really one of the most astonishing, consistent commitments
I believe in the country. And they've done a world of good and I'm very
grateful to them.
I'll always be proud that the first bill I signed as President was the
Family and Medical Leave Act, a law that now has given more than 20 million
Americans the opportunity to take up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave without
losing their jobs. And I remember when I signed it, it had previously been
vetoed on the theory that it would hurt the economic growth of the country. If
that's what it was designed to do, it's been a very poor failure. (Laughter.)
What it has done is to prove that it's good economics to balance work and
family; that the more parents can succeed at home, the more free they are,
psychologically, to be productive at work; and we ought to do more.
I have asked the Congress to include more firms in the Family and Medical
Leave law and to expand the purposes for which people can take family leave.
We have also tried to give states the flexibility to use funds in federal
accounts to help to finance paid leave. We've worked hard on this, and I think
it's very important that we recognize that the United States has done a great
job at creating jobs, but we still give far less support to the responsibility
of balancing work and family than virtually every other industrialized country
in the world. And it is very important to do that.
We've also worked hard to turn teenagers away from unhealthy lives, toward
healthy futures. The rate of drug use has been cut, in part by the powerful
antidrug messages that have been broadcast; and some of you here have helped
us with that. We have done our best to engage the tobacco industry in what has
been a fairly epic and sometimes frustrating struggle to reduce teen smoking.
We made the single largest investment in children's health care since Medicaid
was created. And we're working to get more of our kids -- and increasingly, I
hope, this year, their parents -- enrolled in the Children's Health Insurance
Program. And we're working to make or schools safer.
I think that we also need comprehensive strategies to stem violence both in
and out of schools. Our program would dramatically expand quality after-school
programs. When I started, we had $1 million dollars for after-school programs;
then we went to $20 million; then we went to $200 million. This year we've got
$400 million in after-school programs. And I've proposed $1 billion, and if we
pass it, we'll be able to say that every child, at least in every troubled
neighborhood in the United States of America, can be in an after-school
program. This is a big deal, and I hope you will support it. (Applause.)
I also want to say a word of thanks to all those who have supported
AmeriCorps, including City Year and its other components. We've now had more
than 150,000 young people earning money for college while serving in their
communities. And we're trying to get more and more people to start earlier, to
get high school kids, junior high school kids, involved in community service.
Maryland has become the first state in America to require community service
as a condition of a high school diploma. And listen to this: The study found
that teens who participate in service projects in their communities are 75
percent less likely to drop out of school -- because they're connected in a
way that I think is profoundly important.
Hillary talked about the work we're doing with the industry to give parents
the tools to protect their children in the new media age. I do think we need a
voluntary system that goes across TV, movies and video games. If we can find
some way to develop that, it would make a lot of sense. There's a lot of
information coming at parents -- you know, I try to sort it all out when I see
it. And I think it would be better if there were -- it's almost like you need
a dictionary to explain the differences in the TV ratings and movie ratings
and the video game ratings, so we have to find some way this can be made more
usable.
And today, I want to just mention two things that we're trying to do to
help parents and their teenagers. First, I'm signing an Executive Order to
prohibit discrimination against parents in the work force of the federal
government. (Applause.) Believe it or not, there are still some employers who
are reluctant to hire or to promote employees who have children at home. Some
of you may have experienced this yourselves. The goal of this order simply
says, no glass ceiling for parents. The job they're doing at home is more
important, anyway, and if they can do your job, you ought not to stop them.
Second, I am pleased to announce that our National Campaign Against Youth
Violence, the National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy and Tobacco-Free
Kids, and the national government have teamed up to produce a comprehensive
guide to help parents support their teenagers through this crucial and often
difficult developmental period.
Now, I want to introduce our keynote speaker now, and say I'm sorry that I
can't stay for the rest of the day, but after he speaks I'll have to leave.
But let me say that I want to thank you for coming, again. I want to thank so
many of you here for a lifetime of commitment. People ask me all the time, why
are we focusing on these things when all the indicators are good and things
are going better. This is the time to be thinking about -- I will say again --
how we can deal with the significant challenges of this country. And anybody
that thinks that we've done everything we need to do to help the parents with
teenagers, hasn't had teenagers and hasn't been around lately.
It seems to me that if we can't deal with these big social issues now, when
we're prosperous, when we're doing well; if we can't strengthen the bonds of
our community now, when will we ever get around to doing it. That's why we're
here. (Applause.)
I want to introduce a person who embodies much of the good that's going on
to help parents through having the village do its part -- in the First Lady's
words -- to raise our children. Ben Casey is the President of the YMCA of
Metropolitan Dallas. He has degrees in psychology and counseling from UCLA and
Chapman College. He currently oversees programs -- listen to this -- 145
program centers that serve a quarter of all the families in the greater Dallas
region. We've asked him to speak to us today about his extensive experience
with teens, the wise new poll which also has some important findings about the
way teens and parents view their communication and time together.
And let me just finally say, Mr. Casey, as I bring you up, every minute I
have ever spent with young people, as President and before, but especially as
President, has reaffirmed to me how special they are, what enormous potential
they have. Even the ones that can't make it, really want to and wish they
could. And what a profound responsibility we have. And I want to honor you,
sir, because you spend every day trying to make sure we don't lose a single
one. Thank you. (Applause.)
MR. CASEY: Mr. President, Mrs. Clinton, and distinguished guests. The teen
years should be some of the best years in a person's life. Unfortunately, for
more and more young people, they are becoming the most difficult years of
their lives. One thing is certain: They are the critical years in that they
serve as the basic platform from which the adult is eventually shaped.
For those of you today that are here that are teenagers, I'm going to let
you in on a secret: While you may think that some adults look down on you, the
truth is that almost all of us here today see ourselves still in teen images.
We're always a little surprised to see this older person looking back at us
from the mirror. (Laughter.)
We have all gathered here today to address the special needs of today's
teens. Pressures from school and family and friends can be overwhelming for
many. This generation faces unique challenges that we must all do our part to
help ensure their success.
It's been my privilege to work with young people through the YMCA for 34
years of the 150 years the Y has been committed to community service. These
young people have honored me with their trust. They have shared with me their
most intimate concerns, their aspirations, and their life challenges.
As they struggle to gain the experience and the wisdom to mature, it's
clear that they are in need of support from adults in their lives. There's a
critical need for an adult to care and take the time to listen to our teens.
I still have a vivid memory of Tom, a young man I met at a YMCA mountain
camp. One day, he asked if he could talk to me privately, and he confided to
me that he was considering suicide. When I asked why, he said that he could
not live up to his father's expectations, and he could not live with the shame
of disappointing his father.
I arranged a meeting, and after talking, we learned that Tom's father only
wanted him to have the confidence to reach for the stars, not necessarily, as
Tom had thought, to become a doctor or a lawyer. Tom did go on to succeed in
the arts. And until his father's death, there was no father more proud of his
son.
Communication is the key to developing the relationships teens and parents
need to effectively solve problems together. For this conference, the YMCA of
the U.S.A. has conducted a survey to gauge the effectiveness of communication
efforts between parents and their teens.
It doesn't surprise me that in almost every case, parents have a higher
perception of how effective they are in sharing their values and beliefs than
the teenage daughters and sons. It's for this reason that the YMCA has
launched a nationwide campaign to serve more teens and their families. Our
goal is to serve one in five teens over the next five years.
What we have found in our youth and teen programs in Dallas, is that
today's parents have less family time than their parents did when they were
growing up. Communication has always been difficult; but now that the majority
of parents have full-time jobs and live a fast-paced life, they even have less
time for their teens. We have to look for innovative new ways to solve this
problem.
In order to cut down on the time away from home, the Dallas Y has initiated
a partnership with a grocery store and pharmacy to allow parents to pick up
their groceries, dry cleaning and pharmacy items at the YMCA, at the same time
as picking up their children from our programs. Our only requirement is that
they must go home, turn off the television, have dinner together as a family.
To facilitate family conversations, the YMCA distributes weekly appropriate
stories, with themes for discussion, for these family dinners.
We started this program in response to a working mom's anxiety about not
having time for evening parenting classes that were being offered by the Y.
She shared her overwhelming daily schedule of commuting, work and errands,
that left her exhausted at the end of every day. We realized that family meal
time, as you heard earlier, is quickly disappearing, and the time parents have
to spend with their teens can be dominated by logistics -- did you do your
homework? Have you cleaned your room? Little time remains for quality
conversation, to share concerns, feelings and values.
Today, through our panelists and other experts that we have with us, we'll
learn that teens must be a priority. How can parents learn to communicate
their values and make the time to be a greater part of their teen's lives? How
can teens express their feelings in a way that the parents understand? This is
what today is all about.
There's a quote by H. Jackson Brown, Jr., I'd like to share with,
particularly, parents. He said, "Live that so when your children think of
fairness and integrity, they think of you." I believe in this generation of
young people. I know they are capable of carrying us into the next millennium
and beyond. But first, we must learn to listen to each other. Thank you very
much. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Thank you so much, and I really appreciate your not only
sharing the results of your survey, but even more importantly the results of
your many, many years of work with young people. And we have some terrific
people who are going to be here throughout the day, and we're going to get to
as many as we possibly can.
I want to get right into this panel, and the topic is: Who Are Today's
Teens, And What Do They Need? We have some very impressive panel members, and
they're going to share with us who are these people we call teenagers. We know
they're the most racially and ethnically diverse group of teenagers in our
nation's history. We also know that they have much in common with one another.
The President is fond of quoting Dr. Eric Lander, who spoke at a Millennium
Evening that we held last October, who told us that all human beings have DNA
that is 99.9 percent identical. Now, sometimes when we look at teenagers, we
think they're a different species, but they're not. They are just like us.
(Laughter.) And it should not, therefore, be surprising that they share many
of the same concerns.
And many of the parents are bewildered at how quickly their preteens and
teenage children are growing up these days. They seem to be more mature
physically, and the way that they act. And we have two experts here on the
panel who will talk to us about the changes that occur during adolescence. And
I would like to start with Dr. Jacqueline Eccles, who is a psychology
professor and research scientist at the University of Michigan. Much of her
work has focused on adolescent development. Recently, she chaired the McArther
Foundation Project on Successful Pathways Through Middle Childhood.
She will be followed by Dr. J. Giedd, the Chief of Brain Imaging at the
Child Psychiatry Branch of the National Institute of Mental Health. He's also
a practicing clinician who has written extensively in medical and science
journals on the biological basis of behavioral, cognitive and emotional
disturbances. And he will share with us his recent work on healthy brain
development of adolescents.
So let us begin with Dr. Eccles.
DR. ECCLES: Thank you very much, and I am delighted to be here. Adolescence
begins with the onset of puberty and ends with the transition into adulthood.
For much of the world, this period is rather short, lasting two to three
years. Here and in other Western industrialized countries, the period has
grown to as long as 15 years, because of the time needed to train for
successful employment in our complex and highly technological societies.
I will focus my comments today, however, on the years between 10 and 16,
when most of our young people are still in school and living at home. It is
also our last, best chance to prepare our children adequately for healthy,
happy and productive lives.
Early adolescence, the years from 10 to 14, is one of the most labile
periods in the life span. Rapid changes occur on all levels. This period is
initiated by major changes in the hormonal system, leading to rapid changes in
body morphology. Together, these two biological changes can increase
emotionality and interest in sexuality.
They also affect the way adults interact with our youth in both positive
and negative ways. Some adults see these changes as evidence of increasing
maturity and respond with encouragement, support and excitement. Adolescents
thrive when surrounded with such adults. Other adults see these changes as a
threat and respond with hostility, tighter controls and other unsupportive
behaviors, alienating the very young people who are in their charge.
Rapid changes also occur at the social level. We require most of our
teenagers to make a major school transition, moving from early elementary
school into junior high school or middle school. Unfortunately, the nature of
many of these schools leads to a decrease in close adult contact, and
increases in both the segregation of our youth into peer-oriented groups, and
the alienation of youth from their schools and the larger society. This shift
can be further exacerbated with the later transition into high school.
We also encourage our young adolescents to become involved in heterosexual
activities, like dating, while at the same time providing them very little
guidance related to sexuality, intimacy, and romantic relationships. Given
these two major social changes, it should come as no surprise that adolescents
turn increasingly to their peer groups for guidance and emotional support.
These biological and social changes can also lead to conflicts at home.
This is the period in which our children must mature from dependence on their
parents to taking greater responsibility for themselves. This requires
renegotiating the power relationship between parents and adolescents. In some
families, this renegotiation process can generate conflicts.
What else do we know about this period? First and foremost, most
adolescents and their families weather this period rather successfully.
Nonetheless, about 25 percent of our adolescents and their families are at
risk for less than optimal development during the teenage years. For the most
part, these youth are at risk because we as a society have failed to provide
adequate in- and out-of-school experiences for them.
We also know that it is a time when our children need to figure out who
they are, and what is their place in the larger society. It is a time of
increases in both idealism and cynicism. It is a time for planning and
preparing for the future. And for most youth, it is a time of optimism.
Finally, although we hear a lot about adolescents' desire for independence,
what they want more than anything else is a meaningful role in their
communities. Rather than independence, they want the opportunity to be
effective, contributing members of their society. Unfortunately, we have
failed to provide them with many such opportunities. Raising responsible and
healthy adolescents requires us to provide such opportunities, as well as to
make sure that all of our adolescents are given adequate training to make a
successful transition into adulthood.
Today -- and I emphasize "today" -- we, as a society, are not doing very
well in meeting these challenges. We need to do all we can to make sure all of
our youth have both close, personal relationships with supportive adults, and
the opportunities to be fully participating members of their communities.
(Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Thank you very much, Dr. Eccles. (Applause.) You've raised a
lot of questions, which I hope we can get back to and discuss.
Now I'd like to hear from Dr. Giedd, who will help us understand what
actually may be going on in the brains of young teenagers.
DR. GIEDD: Well, thank you very much. It's an honor for me to be here.
Advances in computers, mathematics and imaging technology now allow us to
examine the developing brain as never before. And what we've found surprised
us. Any parent of a teen can tell you that a nine-year-old and a 13-year-old's
brains are very different. Yet, to actually pin down those brain differences
in a scientific way has been elusive. This is because nature has gone through
a great deal of trouble to protect the brain. It's wrapped in a tough,
leathery membrane, surrounded by a protective moat of fluid, and then
completely encased in bone.
This has shielded it well from falls or attacks from predators; but it has
also shielded it from scientists. (Laughter.) Most ways of looking at the
living brain, such as X-rays or CT scans use harmful radiation that prevent us
from using these to study healthy children.
MRI, or magnetic resonance imaging, changed all that. It allows us to get
exquisitely accurate pictures of the living, growing human brain, and has
helped launch a new era of adolescent neuroscience.
Brain development takes place by greatly over-producing the number of brain
cells and connections. And this is followed by a highly competitive
elimination phase in which only a small percentage of the cells and
connections will make it. This process was thought to occur only in the womb,
maybe during the first 18 months of life. But when we actually followed the
development of children by scanning their brains each two years, we were
amazed to find a second wave of over-production -- a whole decade later than
we had originally thought.
Although the total size of the brain is already 95 percent of its adult
size by first grade, the gray matter or thinking part of the brain continues
to thicken as the brain cells grow extra connections, much like a tree growing
extra branches, twigs or roots.
In the frontal part of the brain, which is involved in planning, judgment
and organization, this over-production process peaks at about age 11 in girls,
and 12 in boys -- about the same time as puberty. Then, the excess connections
are eliminated or pruned, resulting in a thinning of the gray matter. We don't
yet know all the forces that drive this adolescent pruning process; that's the
next phase of our research. But one idea is the "use it or lose it" principle
-- those cells and connections that are used will survive and flourish; those
cells and connections that are not used will wither and die.
We feel this is an incredibly empowering concept for teens. Unlike when
they were in the womb or during the first 18 months of their lives, the teens
themselves can choose their activities and may be able to help guide the
hard-wiring of their brains for the adult years.
It's an unfortunate irony that during this adolescent pruning process, when
the brain is so vulnerable, it's also the time when experimentation with drugs
and alcohol is most likely. It's been very gratifying in my clinical practice
that many teens, armed with knowledge about what's actually happening in their
brains, choose not to take those risks. But sometimes, through no fault of the
parent or teen, the pruning process can go awry. For instance, in childhood
schizophrenia, there is an over-pruning -- as much as four-fold in the frontal
areas of the brain.
The impact of medicines on this process of developmental pruning is largely
unknown. On the one hand, the medication used in teenagers is vastly
understudied, so we don't know many of the potential risks, especially the
long-term risks. But on the other hand, medicines properly used may help the
adolescent have a more healthy brain state, and therefore have more healthy
hard-wiring, and may lessen the need for medicines as an adult. So it's a
complicated issue. There are risks to not using medicines, and there are risks
to using medicines in the teens.
While much work remains to be done, it's clear from a biological
perspective that brain development is far, far from over during the first
years of life. This represents a second chance for teens to make positive
changes for themselves and for their futures. I'm truly thrilled to be part of
this exciting process of discovery, and look forward to striving to provide
information for parents, for teachers, for society, and for the teens
themselves to help optimize the development of their brains.
Thank you. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Thank you very much, Dr. Giedd. I'd like to call on someone,
now, in the audience, because of course there are so many people in this room
who have such a wealth of experience, and it's been very hard figuring out how
we could get everyone to participate. But I would like to ask for comments
from Angela Diaz, the Director of the Mt. Sinai Adolescent Health Center.
DR. DIAZ: Thank you. I would like to say that after 20 years serving
adolescents, I have learned a few things. One of them is that adolescents are
great health care consumers -- if they are engaged and they understand the
process. Also, I have learned that we can have the greatest impact in that age
group, whether we are parents, educators or health professionals.
The other thing that I learned is that we design services for adults, and
then we want to fit teenagers in that model. And when it doesn't work, we
blame them and we call them noncompliant, when, indeed, if we actually
designed services to meet their needs, they would utilize those services. And
those services need to be warm, welcoming; the adolescent needs to feel
respected; they need to be provided at times with those so they can utilize
them, including evening and weekend hours. They need to be provided regardless
of the adolescent's ability to pay for them or not. And they need to honor
confidentiality.
I think parents are the most important things for teens. The teenager needs
their love, their nurturance, their understanding and their advocacy. But at
times, teenagers are not able to tell their parents certain things, and we
need to make sure that we can honor and provide confidential services when
needed. I am the parent of three teens and I certainly hope that if my kids
ever need anything that they cannot tell me, someone would make sure that they
get the services that they need.
The other thing that I want to add is that those services need to be
advertised so that the teens know where to go. And I think that's one of the
beauties of school-based clinics. Because the services are provided right in
school, where the teenagers are. They provide a great opportunity for
follow-up and continuity, and they also happen to be extremely cost effective.
And I also learned that in addition to the physical health of teens, we
need to attend their mental health needs -- whether they are stress related,
depression, abuse or violence. Violence, including abuse, has become the
number one public health issue in my work. I find that adolescent females are
sexually abused more often -- they have a history of sexual abuse more often
than any other condition. I'm in the field for 20 years, and we need to
understand and realize that.
And the last thing that I want to add is that well-intentioned adults --
including parents, educators, health professionals, researchers, policy-makers
and funders -- tend to see adolescent health in a varied problem,
deficit-based way. And we really need to -- that leads to a lot of
fragmentation. We need to move toward a more holistic, comprehensive,
multidisciplinary wellness model, in which appropriate nutrition, fitness, and
adequate sleep form the infrastructure for adolescent well-being.
And I just want to say that as a society, we need to help adolescents grow
up happy, healthy, well-educated, with hopes and opportunities. They are our
thermostat: if they do well, we will do well as a nation. And I think
adolescents are just great. They are terrific. Thank you. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Thank you very much, Dr. Diaz, for your comments. And I'm
glad you mentioned adequate sleep -- (laughter) -- which is an issue that
we're hearing more about these days, as there's more and more research about
how teenagers need more sleep. I don't know, Dr. Giedd and Dr. Eccles, if that
has a biological base. But certainly it seems to have, and that many teenagers
are chronically fatigued, which has to interfere with their biological and
social functioning.
Our next panelist is Karen Pittman, someone I've known for many, many
years, when she and I were both at the Children's Defense Fund. And she was
there working to promote an adolescent policy agenda, and later when she
agreed to serve as the Director of the President's Crime Prevention Council.
Karen is a sociologist by training, a nationally recognized leader in the
field of youth development who helped to launch the movement America's
Promise. She's currently the Senior Vice President of the International Youth
Foundation, which is an organization dedicated to improving conditions and
prospects for children and youth worldwide. And I think Karen has such a
wealth of experience and can help us understand what all teenagers need -- the
assets they need in their lives -- to develop into successful adults.
Karen Pittman.
DR. PITTMAN: Thank you. To answer the question, what young people need, we
have to remind ourselves -- we first have to say, what do we define -- how do
we define success. Too often our messages even today about what we want from
young people are negative. We want them to not get pregnant, not use drugs,
not get in trouble, not be violent. And parents and policy-makers alike are
very concerned about the risky behaviors that threaten young people's futures,
if not their lives.
But few parents stop their list there when they talk about their young
people. Beyond wanting young people to not get in trouble, parents, and I
think all of us, want to see them acquire the attitudes, the values, the
skills and the behaviors that will position them for the future, and for
success.
Problem-free isn't fully prepared. Anyone -- as an employer, if we say, I
have Johnny, he's not in a gang, he's not on drugs, he's not illiterate, he's
not a dropout, he's not a teen father, will you hire him -- hopefully, will
say, what can he do. (Laughter.) So problem-free isn't fully prepared. And
academic confidence, while it is absolutely critical and far too elusive still
in this country for many young people, academic confidence is not enough to
ensure success. We have to make sure that young people have the social,
emotional, vocational and civic confidence that they need, and that we expect
of them.
At the International Youth Foundation, we talk about five Cs -- the fact
that young people need to be competent, they need to be confident, they need
to have character, connections, and we have added the fifth C -- they need to
be contributors. Not just have opportunities to contribute, but have very
clear expectations from us that is what they need to do, as a part of being
teens and as a part of being adults.
If these are the outcomes that we want from young people, what are the
basic inputs? You've heard them today, but I'm going to repeat them anyhow,
since I have a few minutes. What is it that communities must provide in order
to fully expect that our young people, in school or out of school, affluent or
low-income, have the mix of services, supports and opportunities that they
need in order to stay engaged and be full participants?
They are some basic things. First of all -- and we can't underestimate this
-- young people need the basic care and services that were just talked about,
that are affordable, appropriate, and accessible, and if necessary,
confidential. Those services range from health care to transportation. But
services alone are not enough, and services alone, we have learned, will not
draw young people in from the streets or from dangerous behaviors. They need
supports and opportunities.
Young people -- and we've heard this -- need people in their lives. They
need adults who will listen, who will guide, who will respect them, and who
will help them navigate. They need places, safe, stimulating, structured
places where they can live, they can learn, they can work, they can play.
They need possibilities. They need high-quality instruction and training,
not just in the academics, but in anything else they're interested in. They
need opportunities to work. They need opportunities to contribute through
service. We can enlist teens to clean vacant lots; we'd have to also make sure
that they're prepared and ready to advocate for making that lot stay clean
through better zoning and other policies.
We can give young people chances to do job shadowing; but in the end, we
have to make sure they have jobs. The list of inputs that young people need is
not very complicated. But these lists are powerful, and when these inputs are
provided, young people thrive. You've heard that. You'll hear later from Dr.
Blum, who will talk about the fact that we have research that suggests that
the more young people have these basic inputs, the better off they are, the
more likely they are to succeed, the less likely they are to engage in risky
behaviors.
And we know that these inputs cannot be overly-redundant. They have to be
provided in as many settings as possible -- families, schools, youth
organizations, the workplace. These inputs are sensible and they are simple.
As mentioned, America's Promise struck a chord in many communities by offering
a basic list of five fundamental resources: caring adults, safe places, a
healthy start, marketable skills and opportunities to give back. And they
challenged communities to provide all five. There are other lists. The Search
Institute, public-private ventures. We know what young people need. But,
still, these inputs are not available for every teen.
Families play a critical role in being the brokers, the monitors and the
guides for their young people, to make sure they get those services, supports
and opportunities. But there is a cruel irony in the fact that the parents who
have the fewest personal resources live in the neighborhoods that have the
fewest community resources. We have to address that, because too often the
best that a parent can do, while saving the funds to move to a safer place, is
to keep their young person indoors, because the dangerous people, places and
possibilities in their neighborhoods far outweigh the safe ones -- not to even
mention the stimulating ones. And this is a sad commentary on this country.
Saddest, perhaps, is the fact that we really, to date, have no way of
knowing how bad or how good the situation is for individual young people.
Common sense and research suggest that these inputs are cumulative, that the
more teens have the better off they are. But, currently, we have no way to
track how many young people get how many of these resources. We've had lots of
individual data, but we really can't add it up to give this.
And while we know that we have data -- often too much data -- on the
problems that young people have, we have very few ways of knowing how well
they are doing, beyond academic success.
And this really is unfortunate, because the teens and young adults of
America and their families have goals beyond staying out of trouble, and
beyond graduating from high school. Our trend data suggest that problems are
going down. We applaud this; we want it to continue. But we will not see
improvements in teen prospects unless we can ensure that they have a full
array of the people, places, and possibilities that they need to thrive, and a
strong sense that we expect every one of them to do so. Thank you.
(Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Well, we started our program with a video that highlighted
some of the young people who are with us, who did such a good job. Now I think
it's time we heard from another young person. Emily McDonald, who is in our
audience today, is 17. She grew up in Clarkrange, Tennessee, in Appalachia. As
a young child, she was sponsored by Save the Children.
Now, all of us remember Save the Children asking that we sponsor children.
Well, here is one of the children who was sponsored in our own country. She
also benefited from the Head Start program. And today, she's a straight-A
student, a cheerleader, and a dedicated volunteer with Save the Children,
helping to renovate that old Head Start center she attended as a child so it
can serve as an after-school center.
Emily, I'd like you to tell us a little bit about yourself and what you're
trying to do for your community.
MS. MCDONALD: Thank you, Mrs. Clinton, and good morning, everyone. I'm from
a community called Clarkrange, in Fentress County, Tennessee. Our county's
population is approximately 16,000 residents. The annual income for a family
of three is just over $13,000, far below the national average of $20,000.
There are 386 students at my high school, grades 7 through 12. Our area does
not have a lot of resources or activities for young people. And for this
reason, I have seen a lot of youth in my community become involved in drugs
and violence because they do not have good alternatives.
My community and I are very fortunate and thankful to the Save the Children
organization. I have been a sponsored child since age seven. With their help
and the help of my grandmother, Estelle Cooper, who has been an active Save
the Children volunteer since 1968, we are able to offer numerous in-school and
after-school tutoring and mentoring programs, as well as art and reading
programs. We do countless hours of volunteer community service projects and
are able to provide better choices for children from pre-school through high
school.
While giving back to our community, I also have a strong family base and
much love and support, which empowers me to take on large tasks. I am
especially close to my mother and grandmother. They have instilled in me the
values of honesty, responsibility and to always do my best. I feel these
things are important in all areas of life. My family and I enjoy family time,
going to the movies and talking at mealtime -- by supporting each other in all
our individual activities.
After my high school graduation next year I plan to go to college in my
home state of Tennessee and pursue a career in medicine, and also give back to
my community and country. That's the least I think I can do. Thank you.
(Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Thank you so much, Emily. The way that you have described
your connections between your family and your community is exactly what we've
been hearing about today. I think you've got your mother with you today, don't
you? And Mrs. McDonald, why don't you stand up and let us congratulate you on
raising such a responsible and resourceful impressive young woman, as your
daughter. (Applause.)
Now, our next speakers may not be scientists or researchers, but they are
experts. They are the parents of three teenagers. They both used to be six
feet tall before they became the parents of three teenagers. (Laughter.)
I know that everyone in this audience and all of the people who are
following this on the satellite transmission and the different sites around
the country are familiar with the many films and roles that Danny DeVito and
Rhea Perlman have starred in; the television characters they've created on
"Taxi" and "Cheers," and, increasingly, we're familiar with all of the movies
that Danny has produced.
But you may not know about all of the work they do on behalf of children,
most recently as spokespersons for the After School Alliance. And we've
invited them here because they are two parents who have really focused a lot
of energy and concern and love, despite their obviously busy schedules, not
only on their own children, but on children in general, trying to provide
better opportunities for them as well.
And, Danny and Rhea, why can't you give us a few hints, then, about raising
responsible and resourceful teenagers.
MR. DEVITO: You want to go?
MS. PERLMAN: No, you go. Go ahead.
MR. DEVITO: It's negotiation, the whole thing. (Laughter.)
Wow, this is really exciting. First of all, thanks so much for this
opportunity to be here and listen to everybody. I'm writing a lot of things
down that I think I'm going to try to apply.
The one thing that you were saying, Doc, was about, you know, if you told
teenagers, that if they do all these things they're going to lose brain
matter, I think they wouldn't do it. (Laughter.) You know, just show them. Get
a brain before and a brain after -- you see that stuff dwindling down? I
wouldn't do anything. (Laughter.) I mean, that's key, right?
Anyway, I'm really a lucky guy, because I have -- you know, for 17 years
I've been able to come home from work, really come home from work and hang out
with my kids. Ninety percent of the time I'm successful at that. I mean, I try
to do that, and Rhea is the same way. You know, it's like, hey, I eat dinner
with them, and hang out, try to be there while they do their homework. I mean,
I can't go near math or science or anything like that, you know what I'm
saying? (Laughter.) But I can ask them the questions off of those note cards
and things. You know, spell this, or something. As long as I've got the answer
in front of me. (Laughter.)
But you know -- and as they grow older, they have all their own things that
they start getting into. Now I come in the house, and I make sure they know
I'm home, I yell into Lucy's room, I say, Lucy -- she's my 17-year-old, you
know -- and I hear her go like this: hold on a second. Hi, Dad. I'm on the
phone. Okay, all right. So, just want you to know I'm here. And I go to
Gracie's room, and she's on the computer, you know, and she's doing homework,
and I hear the click-click-click-click, the typing going on and stuff. And I
just say, I'm here, you know.
And then I ran out in the hallway, and Jake, who's 12, actually going to be
13 in October. He runs down the hallway -- this you'll appreciate -- he had a
towel, a wet towel, it was all twisted up and wrapped around with rubber bands
and string. And he said, you know, this is a brain -- now this is a brain,
see? It looked like it was in the shape of a brain. He said, you know, Dad,
that if you take the gray matter of a brain and you stretch it out, it would
be the size of an office desk. Right? (Laughter.) Am I right? (Laughter.)
And he uptalks, my son. You know what uptalk is? You know, like, where they
don't end a sentence and they keep talking like this, and they go like that.
And if you take the arteries and capillaries and veins in your body and you
stretch them all around you can go four times around the world? (Laughter.) I
go, uh-huh, okay. Whew, down the block -- he's down the end of the hallway and
I'm left there with a puddle from the dripping towel. (Laughter.)
But uptalk is really interesting. You've probably experienced it, like all
the doctors and people who have studied it. I think it comes from people not
-- you know, kids want to be heard, and they're afraid that if they stop,
adults are going to cut them off and they're not going to talk to them.
So, anyway, I think -- in October, like I said, I'm going to have three
teenagers in the house. I'm not looking for sympathy. (Laughter.) I'm
bragging. I think it's really good. I like hanging out with them. And there
are so many pressures -- teenagers have so many pressures. And a lot of times,
the pressures come from the very people that they turn to for help --
counselors and teachers and parents.
There are so many things going through their head, all kinds of weird
thoughts and whatever, and what do they do? And if they don't have anybody
that they trust, that they can turn to, it's devastating. They're confused, or
they're mad, or they're sad, or a combination of all that at once. It doesn't
matter where a teenager is from, because they're susceptible and it's easy for
them to get into trouble if they have a lot of free time on their hands,
there's no guidance.
I think that's what we have to do -- we have to listen to our kids. And if
we're there all the time, that's okay. And we have to tell them the truth.
That's big. We have to really level with them. It's that seven years between
-- the teenage years when they go from being a kid to being an adult. And I
think it's also a key thing that you make sure you tell your kids that there
was a time when you went through those seven years and you weren't so wise and
so perfect like you are now. (Laughter.) Just tell them that you understand
what they're going through.
This is really good. I am really happy to be here. Thank you. Rhea, you're
probably going to jump in here now. (Laughter and applause.)
MS. PERLMAN: He's such a great dad, really. (Laughter.) We try to spend as
much time with our kids as we possibly can. We're there a lot. We don't go to
see Limp Bizkit concerts with them or anything, or hang around when they're on
the phone. But it's just very important that we stay intimately and deeply
involved with their lives, even though they may be bigger than us and can
drive. (Laughter.)
But when we're not there, we try to know who they're with and what they're
doing and make sure that they've got something valuable going on. But we're
kind of lucky that way because we have excellent resources. And I think that
most parents really want to be with their children a lot, but very few parents
can physically be there for them as much as they would like to because they
work.
And most parents do, and some have two jobs or three jobs, and they don't
have any resources. So if their kid isn't in the school play or in the band or
writing for the paper or on a team, then they have nothing and they don't know
what their kids are doing. And there aren't even grandmas or neighbors around
that much anymore to look in on their kids because they're out working, too.
So to address something that Ms. Pittman was talking about, I think that
kids really need safe places to go after school. Places where they can do
things that make them feel good about themselves -- work on stuff that they're
interested in, get help with their homework, get something to eat if they're
hungry, where they can have access to computers and music, art, sports, where
they can just talk to an adult if they're having a problem, or chill out with
some kids.
So for many years, Danny and I have been working with an organization --
it's a terrific organization called LA's Best. And they set up and run
after-school programs in Los Angeles elementary schools. These programs are
free, they're voluntary. And the sign-up rate is huge. I mean, there are
waiting lists for this program. And the people who supervise the kids -- 90
percent of them are from the community. They're trained; some of them are
salaried, some of them volunteer, and some of them are high school students
who do it as part of their work-study programs, which is great for them as
well.
And the kids in L.A.'s Best love it there. They love it. They feel safer.
They like school more. They get better grades. And then, when they end up
going to middle school, the absentee rate of these kids, compared to the kids
who haven't been through the program, drops way down. This means that they're
staying in school, and this is key, because -- this is a statistic that
someone told me the other day. It says, the correlation between school
dropouts and teen violence is greater than between smoking and lung cancer.
I mean, you know, there's a lot of talk about standards and testing and all
that. I've been reading a lot in the newspaper about this. But if there's
nobody in the classroom, all the standards and the testing in the world don't
mean diddley-squat.
So L.A.'s Best, though, is not in every elementary school, it's in no high
schools or junior highs. And that's only in Los Angeles. So Danny and I have
joined the After-School Alliance, whose goal is to have every child in the
United States have access to quality, affordable after-school care by the year
2010. (Applause.) And that's why the President and the First Lady's commitment
to the 21st Century Community Learning Centers program, which is a federally
funded program to make after-school activities available, is so important.
And I don't want to seem greedy, but -- I am. (Laughter.) We need more. It
seems to me that the federal government, the states, the cities and the
private sector should all pull together to make helping parents take care of
our children a priority. Because parents constantly worry about their kids --
constantly. The period of highest juvenile violence is in the hour after
school ends.
So to know that your kid isn't out on the street or, for that matter, home
alone surfing the channels on the TV, watching who knows what, would bring a
lot of peace. And teenagers are already under so much pressure, as we've
heard, from peer groups, from competition, from school, from their hormones --
to have a positive option, instead of the extra burden of having to fend for
themselves as kids would mean a lot to a lot of kids.
So thank you. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: I thank both Danny and Rhea for sharing those experiences.
And, Danny, thank you for talking about how important it is just to hang out
with your kids -- without an agenda, without a plan, without trying to make
something happen, but just to be there for them and have a chance to learn
about the brain as a wadded-up towel. That's something he wanted to tell you.
MR. DEVITO: That's right. That's right.
MRS. CLINTON: And, Rhea, thank you for yours and Danny's commitment to
after school programs. And I especially appreciate your mentioning how, in
some of the programs older kids, young teens, are among those who supervise
the younger kids, which is such a critical way of giving young people some
responsibility.
One of our problems is that there is not a lot for kids to do anymore.
There aren't the chores that used to be part of daily growing up. And I think
a lot of parents don't either feel they can or think it's kind of a waste of
time to assign those sorts of chores. There's not the daily work that people
had to do. And so we've got to create responsible roles for young people. And
doing what you're doing is so critical to that.
I'm very grateful to this panel, and I'm going to ask the next panel to
come up. And as they do, let's give another round of applause to this panel.
(Applause.) Karen, thank you so much.
MRS. CLINTON: This second panel is focused on what parents can do to help
teens, and what communities can do to help teens and parents. I was very
struck by what Karen Pittman said about how it's often the parents with the
fewest resources who live in the communities with the fewest resources -- the
fewest private resources in the areas with the fewest public resources. And so
we need to be focused on what tools we can give to parents and communities.
You know, David Hamburg, who was instrumental in planning this conference
and who is one of our nation's leading experts on adolescent development,
called our next speaker's recent book, a book that I am reading, which I
recommend to everyone, a book called "Our Last Best Shot" -- Dr. Hamburg
called it the best book on adolescents ever written for the general public.
And that's quite a recommendation.
Laura Sessions Stepp is a Pulitzer prize-winning journalist from The
Washington Post. But she's here today to share with us what she learned in
researching her book, which is really a road map for parents navigating the
challenging teen years.
And she will then introduce our two next speakers, who are aptly named Edd
and Edwin Speaker, which is very appropriate, who are featured in a chapter in
her book that is called "Am I Competent?" which echoes some of our earlier
panelists' comments about the importance of teens feeling competent.
So let me now turn to Laura Sessions Stepp.
MS. STEPP: Thank you, Mrs. Clinton, for inviting me to speak in front of
this most distinguished and caring group.
I'd like to start by telling two short anecdotes. One night, three years
ago, in a small Kansas town called Ulysses, a 13-year-old named Shannon spent
an hour complaining to me about her mom, Brenda. Mom got onto her about
e-mail; Mom got onto her about her grades; her litany was as long as her face.
And, yet, as soon as she got home, she headed straight for mom and gave her a
big hug and said, mom, I love you.
In Durham, North Carolina, a 14-year-old named Mario had to sit out 8th
grade because he had been suspended from school. When I asked him what was
good about his life, he answered quickly, my parents, I be doing everything
with them.
These stories illustrate a significant point: No matter how teenagers may
criticize their mom and dad, parents matter to them a lot. Think about the
poll Mrs. Clinton mentioned earlier: Three out of four teens wish they had
more time with their parents -- three out of four. That doesn't surprise me.
When I began researching my book, I really wanted to look at kids'
relationships with people other than parents -- coaches, teachers, mentors.
The kids, themselves, kept leading me back to their families. And what I
learned from following those 18 families over two years is that closeness with
teens is earned, it's not a given.
The closeness is earned in three ways. I call these concepts the three R's
of raising teens. Parents who raise healthy teens so respect for their kids'
rapidly growing minds and bodies; they give their kids an increasing amount of
responsibility; and they work at keeping a close relationship with them.
Respect, responsibility and relationship are what's important, all the rest is
details.
For example, in Kansas, Jack Richardson's mom, Gay, agreed to let him rope
bulls in rodeo arenas when he was 12. That's respect. Edwin Speaker, whom you
will meet in a few minutes, was selling art and incense for his mom on
California's Venice Beach, also by age 12. Can you imagine letting your child
run a booth, by himself, among hundreds of hucksters and weirdos on Venice
Beach? (Laughter.) More comical, can you imagine your face when he brings home
$300 for one day's work? Now, that's responsibility.
Libby Segal, a 7th grader in Los Angeles, was caught smoking marijuana and
drinking at a party. When her mother, Rebecca, picked Libby up and took one
whiff, she could easily have blasted her with accusations. Instead, she asked
a pointed question. What does it mean to do this with your friends, she asked.
She forced Libby to think, even in her altered state. Rebecca told Libby, your
friends' actions affect you, but you affect them, too.
You see, she respected her daughter's thinking skills, even though she knew
her judgment had failed temporarily. She reminded Libby that she was
responsible for herself and for others. And most importantly, she kept that
relationship going through what could have been a disaster by asking questions
calmly.
I've developed a theory about successful parenting relationships from years
of writing about teenagers. Parents who do almost anything for their young
children continue to make tangible sacrifices to stay close to their kids in
adolescence. Some work split shifts so that a parent is always home. Some
volunteer in school on their lunch hour. They listen to their kids, the
smallest details that their kids want to share, and they never, ever give up
on them.
One last story. Shannon, the Kansas girl who complained first and hugged
second, continued to have a rocky relationship with her mother after I left
that family. Two years after I left, she injured herself intentionally.
Fortunately, she survived. Her mother, Brenda, hung in there, and a year
later, after she had done that, Shannon gave her mom a cross-stitch wall
hanging, and on it were the words, "If I didn't have you for a mother, I'd
choose you for a friend."
Thank you very much. (Applause.)
And now it is my very great privilege to introduce Edd and Edwin Speaker,
the father-son duo who fill the first chapter of "Our Last Best Shot." Edd
grew up in Texas before moving to Los Angeles. He's an insurance claims
consultant and has four children. Edwin, despite how big he is, he's his
youngest. Edd and his ex-wife, Dorothy, split up when Edwin was seven. Edwin
lives with his dad who, out of necessity, became a master at networking for
his son.
Edwin, a high school freshman when I met him, and considerably shorter, is
now a senior in high school. He's a talented drummer and disc jockey, and has
plans -- at least, I think he has plans to become a sound engineer. Edd
Speaker.
MR. SPEAKER: Thank you. It's an honor to be here, and to be among such
great minds. You know, I sat and I listened to all the comments that have been
made about the development of children. And you know, I kind of wondered, I
said, well, who showed everybody what I was going to say? (Laughter.) Because
most of the points that I intended to make have been touched on. And to me,
that just kind of solidifies the thought that we all have a common goal, we
all have a common caring about our kids.
And being a single parent, there have been a number of obstacles that I've
faced as a single parent, and that I think all parents face, whether they be
single parents or two-family parents. And the number one obstacle being to
provide a safe environment -- to have an after-school program where you don't
have to worry about what's happening to your kid, what type of influences that
they're being exposed to, and that you can go about your daily job of earning
a living for the family.
I think that in order to be a successful parent, in addition to being
involved with your child on a daily basis, you have to start by networking.
I've been asked a number of times, you know, tell us what you've done to be a
successful parent. And I started by networking. And the question comes back,
well, what does networking do?
Networking basically provides you with a base of resources. And when I say
networking, I mean talking to other parents that have the same common sharing,
that have the same goals, that may know about programs, that may know about
resources that you don't know -- listening to these parents and taking
advantage of them.
I started in the church. You know, Edwin and I are very religious people,
and our entire moral basis is based on things that we've learned right and
wrong, and we started in the church. In my church, I was talking with a church
member who informed me about a sports clinic. I went to the sports clinic, I
talked with a parent at the sports clinic who told me about Challengers Boys
and Girls Club, which is a member of the Boys' and Girls' Club of America.
I went over to Challengers, and they said, oh, yes, we've got a
transportation program, we can pick you kid up from school, bring him here,
help him with his homework, and you come by after you get off from work. I
said, gee, how in the world am I going to afford something like this. They
said, well, it's $25 a year. You may not be able to afford it. And I was
really excited about the fact that this wide array of services was available.
So I decided that I would become intensely involved with this organization,
as well as with other community organizations, and that I would bring my son
along, and try to show him rather than tell him. So I was constantly there
with him. We were constantly involved. He's evolved into a quite a young man
and I'm really proud of him.
One of the things I will say is that it would not be fair for me to try to
take all the credit for Edwin's development. People come to me, they say,
you've got such a great son, you did such an outstanding job. And while it's
true he is a great son and a fine young man, I can't take all the credit for
it. He has a strong relationship with his mom, he sees her on a regular basis.
There are other people that obviously have influenced his life -- his
teachers, there are other mentors. It takes a village to raise a kid; and
while we all want to take all the credit, it's just not fair.
And I think, even more importantly so, is that a certain amount, if not a
major part of it, goes to Edwin, because he's the one that makes the choice. I
mean, you can present all these things, you can bring all the programs, you
can have all the resources that you want -- but the kid still has to make a
conscious decision: Yes, I want to be this way; yes, I want to be the kind of
person that adults respect, that my peers like me. And I think he's made a
conscious decision to be this kind of person.
I could go on and on naming all the things that he's done and the things
that I've been concerned about, but I think that I can sum it up by saying
that as a parent, we all constantly reach for the kind of positive personality
components and character elements that we want our kid to have. But it's up to
the kid to make these choices. And the one thing that we can do is that we
have to embrace our children, we have to love them and just never, ever stop
pushing them to be the best that they can be. (Applause.)
And it's also quite an honor to be here and to be able to share this with
my son. We started out as a father and son team, about 10 years ago, he was
six years old, and we had no idea that we would ever be in such an audience
and such a place. And I'd like to introduce him and have him say a few things.
Edwin, stand up. (Applause.)
EDWIN SPEAKER: It's truly an honor to be here, to speak in front of the
First Lady, and even to see the President is a real honor. And me and my dad,
we're like a normal family. We don't see it as doing different things, we just
do it as normal. Like me being involved in the Boys and Girls Club helped a
lot. I have a lot of mentors, they taught me a lot of different things. I was
in a lot of different programs.
And I think if it wasn't for my dad, where would I be? Because like I said,
it takes a man to raise a man. (Applause.) I mean, I give credit to my mom,
too, but I owe it most to my dad. He took me fishing. We used to go out to the
ball game. He was involved in a lot of programs in the club. It's because of
that, that I think I'm here today. I just owe most of the credit to him.
That's all I have to say. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Laura Stepps' book talks a lot about the question that she
poses: Am I competent? -- is a child competent to do something and feel good
about himself. And, certainly, Edd and Edwin are examples for all of us who
know that there are challenges that have to be overcome in everyone's life.
But seeking that commitment to overcome them and create that competence --
and I like Laura's three R's of respect, responsibility and relationship --
but I think you summed it very well, Mr. Speaker, when you talked about show
me, not tell me. And there really is not any substitute for that.
And I think partly because of time pressures and because we are living in
such a non-stop, talky culture where people are just talking at us and
sometimes you turn on TV, they're yelling at us -- people think that talk
substitutes for action, and that as long as you're a good talker, it doesn't
really matter what else you do. And that has permeated our culture.
So the idea, the slogan, "show me, don't tell me," that's the way you build
competence. You can tell somebody something over and over again, but only by
showing them and exemplifying the characteristics you want do you really have
a chance of creating the sort of person that you hope to have.
Now, our next speaker, Dr. Robert Blum, is the Director of the Division of
General Pediatrics and Adolescent Health at the University of Minnesota, and
is a co-investigator for the seminal national longitudinal study on adolescent
health known as ADD Health.
This important research holds very significant information about the
influence of social factors and connections to the health of teenagers. And I
think it's important that we know what this research is demonstrating, because
sometimes your experience may not be enough; you may feel somewhat doubtful
about your own experience, or even about what somebody else tells you. But
backing up that experience with the research may help to, I hope, change some
people's minds about what we need to do. Dr. Blum?
DR. BLUM: Thank you very much. Mrs. Clinton, I wasn't going to comment, but
you raised the issue before about chores. And there actually has been
research, and we've done some of the work with kids with disabilities. And
what we found is that chores, having responsibilities, is a non-verbal message
that you matter in my family. And kids who don't have chores get the message,
you don't count.
I'd like to structure my comments, based on ADD Health, around four myths.
Myth number one: Families don't matter. By the time we reach adolescence, it's
all in the genes -- spell it whichever way -- (laughter) -- or peers.
What do we know? We know that families in fact do matter, and continue to
matter throughout the teenage years. In the original analyses of ADD Health,
family connectedness was associated with delay in sexual debut, less cigarette
smoking, less alcohol use, less emotional distress and suicidality, and less
violence. We have also found that adolescent perceptions, what kids believe --
particularly about maternal disapproval of sex -- are associated with delay of
first intercourse. Parents' perceptions, on the other hand -- what mom says
she believes -- has no such association with delay of first intercourse.
What influences perception? Perceptions don't seem to be influenced by the
amount of talk. They seem to be influenced, as we have seen this morning, by
the interaction of caring and connectedness, on the one hand, and clear and
consistent messages.
Myth number two: parents need to be home after school to monitor their kids
more. There's value to being home after school. But what we know is that
monitoring without connectedness has little associated protective effect.
Where it does, it's mostly with older teenagers, and it's limited to certain
substance abuse.
Likewise, while there are less health-risk behaviors found in teenagers
whose parents are home more times during the day -- at breakfast, after
school, dinner, and at bedtime -- there are no magical times of the day. And
after school is no more magical than any other time.
Myth number three: Do things with your kids. You know, take your kid
hunting and you won't have to go hunting for you kid. And Edwin, as much as
your dad took you to ball games, I don't think that was the answer.
Doing activities with parents by itself is associated with very little risk
reduction. Going shopping, tossing a football, does not create connectedness.
Psychological availability does. The key is giving a young person the
consistent message that they're crazy about them. Yuri Bronfman-Brenner said,
every kid needs someone who's crazy about them.
Myth number four: The real issue is family divorce. I was in the House Ways
and Means Committee office antechamber, and there was a big poster. With a red
light, it said, "Stop juvenile violence." And a green light, it said, "Start
two-parent families." Would that we could.
But underlying this is the assumption that the answer is two-parent
families, and the problem is single parents. What do we know? Well, young
people who come from single-parent families are more likely than others to be
involved in every risk behavior. The vast majority of these young people are
not involved. Additionally, and importantly, coming from a single-parent
family explains less than two percent of alcohol use; less than two percent of
weapon-related violence; very little suicide risk at all; very little
difference between those who have had early sexual involvement. Clearly,
things other than the family is going on.
What matters? For violence risk, what we see from ADD Health: school
failure, victimization -- and Dr. Diaz spoke to that -- future plans, friends
drinking, friends' suicide or suicide attempts, and access to weapons at home
all are associated with violence risk.
For substance abuse: temperament, early physical maturation, peer drug use,
parent smoking, parent drug use.
For suicide attempts, factors that increase risk include poor school
performance, sexual victimization and low self-esteem. For every group, when
we looked at suicide attempt, family connectedness clearly reduced suicide
risk, no matter what else was going on.
For sexual relations, whether you're male or female, black, white,
Hispanic, being in a relationship greatly increases your risk of early sexual
intercourse. As opportunities increase, not surprisingly, so does the
likelihood of sexual intercourse. On the other hand, those young people who
see pregnancy as having a high personal cost -- for their reputation, for
themselves, for their future -- are much more likely to delay intercourse.
What can we conclude? When we look at the factors that place young people
at risk for a range of what Lee Shore (pho.) calls "crummy outcomes," we
consistently see school failure as part of the picture. School failure is a
public health problem for youth. (Applause.)
It is influenced in part by parental attitudes towards school. Parents who
highly value school have kids who are much more connected with school, and it
is very protective. So, too, family connectedness is strongly associated with
school connectedness. And these, family and school, are the two major
institutions in the lives of young people.
Families matter. But only in connection with school, with church, with
other community institutions can they be successful. Parents can't do it
alone, and we should stop expecting them to. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: You know, clearly from Dr. Blum's comments, the whole issue
of connectedness, and the psychological availability that parents have to
their children, is becoming a theme of today's conference. But I think it's
often difficult for parents to translate that into what they're supposed to do
every day, because each of us inherits, both perhaps biological and
environmental, our own ability to be psychologically available, our own
openness, our upbringing influences, how we relate to our children.
So are there ways that we can help parents know what that means? Because
for the people who might be watching this or reading about it, Laura writes
about all these parents, and I'm reading her book. You know, every one of them
wakes up in the morning trying to do what she or he thinks is best for the
child or children in that family.
There are very few parents -- I mean, there are some -- but there are very
few parents who deliberately set out to undermine their child's competence,
destroy the connectivity, and create a child who is at risk of failure or who
has one of the problems we're talking about. So before we go on to the next
speaker, I'd like to ask three panelists who have already spoken, perhaps, to
just say a word: how do you become better connected? How do you become
psychologically available?
And Dr. Blum, what I basically heard you say is that -- and Mr. Speaker
said the same thing -- that one of the reasons you network and you find other
adults who are responsible to be part of your children's lives is to make up
for your own deficits. You may recognize things about yourself that you may
try to work on, but you're not going to be the best, most available parent
there is. So you try to find a Challengers Boys and Girls Club. You encourage
your child to be active in a religious activity, or something like that. Is
that one of the answers? Laura?
MS. SESSIONS STEPP: It certainly is. Another thing is that I think you can
plug into their world. Ms. Perlman mentioned not going to Limp Bizkit
concerts, so I'm not saying we all have to listen to, God help us, Limp
Bizkit. But it is important to know who Limp Bizkit is, and to have listened
to some of those Cds, so that you know what it is your child is listening to,
and you have that basis for conversation when they're ready to talk to you
about it. So there are ways to sort of be on the edge of your child's life,
but still be connected to the center.
DR. BLUM: We went and spoke with young people and said, how do you know
when your parents are connected? And they had wonderful and clear examples. A
note on the refrigerator that says, Jimmy, I'm going to be home late from work
today. There's a sandwich in the refrigerator for you. I'll be back at 5:00
p.m. A phone call from work after school to say, how did your day go? I'm
going to be tied up. Being there when I come home at night.
My father, who knows the name of the guy that I went out with, and doesn't
say, how was the date that you had with What's-his-name? My mother who
remembers that I had a math test last Thursday and said, how did you do on
that math test, and didn't forget about it. All of those things say, you
count.
MRS. CLINTON: Mr. Speaker?
MR. SPEAKER: Well, just to kind of piggyback on what Dr. Blum is saying, I
think that certainly these are things that give an indication that you do
count. And they are things that I, as a parent, try to practice, by being
involved and knowing exactly where Edwin is and what he's doing, and knowing
times -- there are times, again, it looks like he's reading my mind, because
there are times when I'm not going to be home that I'll leave some money on
the table and say, you know, get you something to eat. I'll be a little late,
and then I'll call and make sure where he is. And I'll try to keep track of
his social development, where he goes, who he's with, who he's seeing.
And I think that he probably thinks that I'm kind of overprotective, but
there are just so many things that are happening out there. And I've tried to
stay on top of it at all times. I think it's important in the development of
our kids that we're there and we know -- we've got to know what's going on,
whether they like it or not. And it can be done from a positive stance, by
just saying, yes, I care. I want to know. I want to know who this guy is. Who
are his parents? What do they do? It's just a thing that you have to do.
MRS. CLINTON: I really appreciate that, because I think we want to send
some strong messages today, but we don't want people to feel sort of helpless
about how they can translate all of this experience and advice into sort of
day-by-day activities. And as I was listening, I was remembering a
conversation that I once had with a friend of mine, Janet Hill, who is the
mother of Grant Hill and the wife of Calvin Hill. And they led very busy
lives, but they just had hard and fast rules about staying in contact.
And Janet used to tell me that she had a set time every day, if she wasn't
going to be available physically, to call and talk with Grant. So even if she
was on the other side of the world, at 3:00 p.m. or 4:00 p.m. -- I can't
remember what time it was exactly -- she'd set the alarm clock, she'd wake
herself up, she'd call. She would make sure he knew she was thinking about
him, so that the psychological availability, which creates the psychological
space, which is really where we conduct most of our lives together, was always
available. And I think that that's something that anyone, even a busy parent,
if they're constantly thinking about their child and reaching out, can try to
manage to do.
Our next speaker who is in the audience today is one of our nation's
leading authorities on work and family issues. Ellen Galinsky is the cofounder
and president of the Families and Work Institute, which conducts pioneering
studies on the ways that job and home life inter-relate. And her recent book,
"Ask The Children," challenged some of the conventional wisdom about
children's views of their parents' work.
And Ellen has really been a pioneer in making all of us stop and think
about some of those issues. And I remember so well when I was a young lawyer
working how there were rules in a lot of the places, not only that I
represented and visited, that you could not make personal phone calls.
And around 2:30 p.m., 3:00 p.m., 3:30 p.m., every afternoon, you'd see all
the women who worked in those offices sneaking around to call their children,
to make sure that their children got picked up, that they got home, that they
were taken care of. How much better it would be if offices said, look, we need
you to be a good employee and one of the ways we're going to do that is by
supporting you in being a good parent; so for goodness' sake, you've got
permission to call and find out whether your child is home safely.
It's those little things that make a big difference, because they undermine
this psychological availability. And I think there are a lot of parents who
are caught in a double-bind, who feel that they can't express at work what
they need to in terms of staying in touch with and connected with their
children. So, Ellen, will you tell us what employers can do to help their
employees who parent teenage children to be better at that important job.
MS. GALINSKY: I'd like to point out a trend in this conference that we
haven't talked very much about, before I address your question. And that is,
we've all talked about the fact that this conference is bringing us a new view
of parenting a teenager; it's not just the problems, but we're looking at the
promise, the potential of young people.
But the other thing that we're doing that is unusual and I do think is a
part of a trend, is that we're listening to children. We're not just talking
about children and communicating within families; but we as a society have
brought children here and we're listening to children -- it changed the book
that you've written, it has changed the way you parented, and so forth.
So I did the same thing in thinking about how to answer your question. I
looked at what children say they need. And the answers won't be particularly
surprising, but -- I think, actually, they are surprising -- but I think that
they're very important.
The first is, and we've talked about it, the importance of flexibility of
time, that the amount of time is not necessarily so important as having
flexibility in time. And it's not just little children who need that. When I
looked at whether children felt that they had enough time with their parents,
it was older children, more so than younger children, who were yearning for
time with their parents. One in four companies provide flexibility on a daily
basis for parents.
The second issue is -- and I think Mrs. Clinton just talked about this --
is having support that's without jeopardy, that you don't have to sneak around
to make a phone call. And it's important that be true for mothers as well as
for fathers. I found when I asked the children, for example, what was
important to them, they were particularly yearning for more time with their
dads, even a bit more so than their moms. So we need to make sure that when we
think of employer supports at the workplace that we're thinking of fathers, as
well as thinking of mothers.
We've been talking about the importance of networks and support. And the
workplace is a very important place to have that happen. A recent study that I
just did of kids, I found that 80 percent of them said that their mothers
worked most of the time that they were growing up; and 86 percent of them said
that their fathers worked most of the time when they were growing up, so the
workplace is an important place that can provide support for families and to
help parents navigate, as you say, those tough moments in being a parent.
I asked kids, for example, what are some of the most important things that
they can do, and they talked about the importance of being able to talk to
them. They said -- one 14-year-old, don't be afraid to talk to your kids. They
may act like they don't want to, but talking to them is great, and they want
you to whether you think they want to or not. So help at the workplace with
how do you talk to kids. And in fact, I once did a seminar when I brought in a
group of teenagers to talk to the corporate audience about when does it work
in talking to your kids, and when is it a disaster, and what differentiates
those two things.
The other thing we've been talking about all morning, too, which is that
the small moments make a big difference. When I asked children what they would
most remember from this period in their childhood, it was those small moments,
those everyday moments -- the song that you sing when you wake up your kid;
the note on the refrigerator that you're coming home -- that make the biggest
difference. And we can get that kind of support and we can learn those little
tricks from each other at the workplace, particularly since so much of us
spend so much time there.
The fourth suggestion that I have also comes from kids. When I ask children
if they had one wish and I just gave them one wish for what they would change
to change the way their mother's or their father's work affects their lives,
children said that they wished that their parents were less stressed and less
tired. And that's an issue that we've skirted around the edges of all day.
It's a surprise -- only two percent of parents guessed that their kids would
say that, by the way.
Work is becoming more demanding. But interestingly enough, I also found
that when parents have good jobs -- and that means that they're reasonably
demanding, that means that they have some autonomy in their job, that means
that they don't have to pretend that they don't have a life outside of work at
the workplace, that their supervisors are supportive, things like that, they
not only come home less stressed, which I think has health repercussions, but
they also have more energy for their kids. But, I think importantly, they go
back to work ready to invest that in the workplace. So it's not a win-lose,
it's not an either/or situation the way we think it is. A good workplace can
lead to better parenting and lead to better workers at the workplace.
Now, unfortunately, only 12 percent of employers are doing something
specifically to help parents of teenagers. So I hope that this conference will
be the clarion call that helps this be the next frontier for the workplace.
Thank you. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: You know, Ellen's contribution to this is so important,
because for a long time, our national dialogue about work and family has
focused mostly on young children -- how do we provide child care for the
preschooler, how do we take care of the third- and fourth-grader who is going
to get out of school and has nowhere to go.
But we now know how important it is that parents have these flexible times
and these moments and this support in parenting their teenagers as well. And I
really appreciate Ellen's leadership in this effort.
Another area where parents are asking for help is monitoring their teens'
television and Internet and video game and music usage. And as I said earlier,
I really think we need a voluntary, uniform rating system that will tell all
parents in a simple and consistent way whether the material their children
wish to view is appropriate.
But until we have such a system in place, we at least have a variety of
ratings that we can rely on, but a lot of parents don't even know about those
ratings and find them confusing and, therefore, unhelpful, and in addition,
don't know how to use the V-chip, either.
Now, as we know from the poll that was released this morning, parents think
they are supervising their children's Internet usage. But I don't think it
will surprise any of us that their teenage children tell a very different
story. They don't think they're being supervised at all, and if they have
parents like me, they don't think that their parents could supervise what
they're doing, so they feel pretty much unsupervised. I'm hopeful that the
Task Force on Tools for Parents and Teens in the Media Age will help address
this important point.
Our next speaker from the audience will speak about the responsibility of
the media and entertainment industry to develop these tools for parents so
that parents can better understand and monitor the new media.
Judith McHale is the President and Chief Operating Officer of Discovery
Communications and Chair of the Board of The National Campaign to End Youth
Violence. She has been a terrific bridge between the world of family and work,
between the public and the private sectors. I can't thank her enough for the
leadership she's given on so many important issues.
And we've asked her to share her views regarding the role of the media.
Judith?
MS. MCHALE: Thank you, Mrs. Clinton, and thank you for hosting this amazing
conference. As a mother of a teenager, I'm taking copious notes as we go
through it. You speak about the role of media and the responsibility of the
media. One of the sort of trends I hear through this is communication and the
importance of communication with your teenagers.
At the same time, when we are being bombarded with changes in media, the
technological changes around the world are absolutely stunning, and the
choices that our children have to make every day, the images all of us are
constantly being hit with I think are creating huge, huge obstacles to those
moments of communication. And what should we and what should our role in the
media be as we look at it.
I think one of the things that I sort of tried to, as I've stepped back and
looked at it is this question of -- you probably can't shield them from
everything that's going on; that would be an impossible task. But why not take
steps to harness the incredible potential power of all of this sort of
information that's going around and use it in good and positive ways.
Now, that's easier said than done for most parents. Mrs. Clinton, you
alluded to how difficult it is to monitor your kids' behavior, and I would say
there's nothing more -- no more hunbling experience than I had this morning,
standing behind my 11-year-old, helping me to -- my way through a computer. I
think we have a different kind of digital divide going on between techno-savvy
kids and their parents. So it makes it very, very difficult for you to
understand all that's going on. And, frankly, I think it's frightening for a
lot of us.
When you sort of see that your 11-year-old or your 17-year-old is far more
sophisticated than you are in wending and navigating their way through this
new world, how, indeed, are you going to be able to help them out. And I think
we in the media have a responsibility to help develop tools and communicate
tools to parents and to others to do that, to parents to provide them with the
resources that they need to understand the information that is flowing into
their homes or into their schools that their kids are dealing with.
I think someone -- Mrs. Clinton, you might have mentioned earlier, to get
that wise site on the Internet with helps parents understand the kinds of
resources that are out there and guides for the kids. I think tools for
families to help them share some of these experiences together -- we've --
Discovery launched our Internet site and we kept in mind families and tried to
develop a tool that would allow families together to explore the net.
But most importantly, I think we need to develop tools for kids, with kids,
to help them understand the messages that they are receiving in all these new
ways. We spend hundreds of hours in schools, year after year, helping kids
interpret the written word, but we've done very little to this point to help
them interpret electronic media and the messages that they're getting from a
variety of other ways.
One of the things that I've been trying to do -- and we've developed a
program at Discovery which, last week, I announced we were going to take into
every school in the state of Maryland, a media literacy program, which is
absolutely designed to help kids understand the messages that they're getting
over television, through the net, what have you.
And last year, when we launched -- started looking into this program, I
took it into some schools in Maryland myself and went around to see them, and
at every level, it was one of the things that the kids really wanted. And it
was amazing -- we went to a high school in Bethesda and it was with a sort of
fear and intrepidation, launching a new program there in front of 500 kids in
high school. And we went through the whole program, it's highly interactive,
where they can really see the news, see sports events, how they are portrayed
on television, and begin to interpret it. And at the end of it -- we ended
early -- one of my favorite anecdotes was, the principal at the school said,
okay, why don't you guys give us your feedback. I was totally terrified that
when you're dealing with kids this age, what were they going to say about this
boring message.
And I always remember one kid stood up and I would say he was about 16 or
17, and sort of had a scarf on his head. And he looked at me and he said, you
know -- he goes, this was really cool. And which, obviously, as the mother of
a teenager, knew this was high praise -- and he goes, of course, you've ruined
television for me, but that's okay, this is really cool. And you found the
kids wanting to be totally engaged in this process, to really understand. When
you are able to explain to them the impact of violence on them -- I go back to
your brain research -- when they understood the impact of some of the football
images that they received, or baseball, or the more violent images or even
sitcoms, the editorial choices that people were making, they felt empowered.
And I think in the media, we have a responsibility to take those steps to
empower kids, to understand the messages that we're receiving, to understand
what's real, what's make-believe, and in the end, to understand what's right
and wrong. Thank you. (Applause.)
I think Judith's point is especially important, because one of the
challenges that we face is helping our children understand what the media
messages are and what the advertising messages are, and to sort of deconstruct
that, if you will, so that they are less influenced by them. You know, to see
sort of what the motives behind a lot of advertising are, and not to be taken
in or taken advantage of.
Because one of the concerns we hear a lot about is the way young people are
both depicted in the media and the way young people are increasingly viewed
not as future citizens, not as individual human beings with promise and
potential, but as consumers, and therefore, as manipulable objects that can be
driven in one direction or another to achieve certain commercial ends.
And we see how the unrealistic images of women and girls inspire unhealthy
dieting and eating disorders, we see the racial and ethic stereotypes that are
still such a part of our media, we see how common, gratuitous sex and violence
are and we know that this steady diet of media images, even if we believe we
are strong enough to sort them out and stand against them, send messages and
affect the way people view themselves and others.
Now, our next speaker, also in our audience, has studied these issues and
drawn some interesting conclusions about the implications of media's depiction
of teens.
Susan Bales is the President of Frameworks Institute, a project of the
College-University Resource Institute, which conducts communications research
on social issues. And I'd like to ask if Susan Bales would tell us: Is there a
danger in the media's portrayal of young people today and what we can do about
that.
MS. BALES: Thank you, Mrs. Clinton, friends and colleagues. I think there
is a serious distortion in the way that the media presents youth today. And
while we talk a lot about is consequences on youth, I think we're less aware
about its consequences upon us as adults -- first, as parents in the way that
we view our child's peer group and teens in general, but secondarily -- and I
think even as important -- is in the way that we view ourselves as citizens
and make decisions about priorities for public spending.
So I want to talk just a little bit about the research we've conducted for
the last year with funding from the W.T. Grant Foundation. Looking at survey
research, we see that adults believe that teens today are different than they
were in the past. Only one in six adults will tell you that teens today share
their moral and ethical values.
When asked what descriptors they would use to describe teens today, they're
more likely to talk about materialistic and selfish teens. If you ask what
they would have described teens 20 years ago, those words were more like
patriotic and idealistic.
The reality, as we know, is the reality that we've talked about here today.
When you ask kids what values they hold to be important, they will tell you
that it's honesty and hard work, it's performance in school, and it's giving
and helping others. And yet, if you present adults, parents with information
about what kids are actually doing in the world, that they're volunteering,
that they are attending cultural events, that they are succeeding in school,
it is the rare parent that will believe these statistics.
What accounts, then, for something so powerful that it trumps our own view
of reality? My friend, Catherine Hinds Knowles (pho.), who is here in the
audience, says that television is a great cultural storyteller, and that we
get a lot of the information that we have about the other from television.
In a review that she just did for us of the fall evening entertainment
lineup and its presentation of youth, Catie found a world that sounds entirely
disconnected from the world that we've described here today. She found that TV
teens are entirely disconnected from their communities. In fact, they're
disconnected from their parents. Parents are often shown as -- if they're
shown -- uninvolved, ineffective, often they cause problems that teens must
solve. The teens solve those problems in conjunction with their peer group,
and the problems that they solve are often trivial and social in nature.
On the news side, a recent study from the Berkeley Media Studies Group
showed that there are two issues that dominate in television news as it
affects youth: Crime and education. And those have equal prominence in print
coverage. So if you think about it, we are showing violence as a presence in
our children's lives to the same degree that we are showing violence and
crime.
The writer, Richard Rodriguez has said that the stories invent us. I think
what we are seeing in the way that we view both television, news and
entertainment, is that we're making some false risk assessments. We are being
told that a good parent is one who protects his or her adolescent from the
community at exactly the time that experts in this room would tell us that our
adolescents need to be acculturated into the community.
That also has consequences for us in that the more that teenagers are
removed from the community, the less actual contact we have with them, and the
more likely we are to believe these false images of today's youth.
I think we need a different kind of television, news and entertainment. We
need to see more kids working in soup kitchens, doing performance arts, on
track for achievement, and we need to see them in ways that allow us to
believe the regularity of their lives, not the dissimilarities.
I think that we need to tell ourselves a new story about youth in America
today, and that unless we are able to tell ourselves a new story, we are more
likely to make very bad public pronouncements and public judgments. And those
judgments are more likely to go in the direction of incarceration, metal
detectors and remedial decisions about children's lives, instead of positive
promotion. Thank you. (Applause.)
MRS. CLINTON: Susan, before you sit down, could I ask you to respond? As I
travel around and meet with a lot of parents and others, I cannot tell you how
many adults, and particularly parents, are so emotionally disturbed by this
constant diet of youth violence that the news feeds. And of course, we've had
some terrible, tragic incidents that have broken through national
consciousness, and they are living in such a state of fear about their own
children.
And because their sense of perception is at variance with their everyday
reality, how does one in my position, your position, any of our positions, how
do you respond? Because if you say, but you know, the statistics are that
youth homicide and suicide are going down, thankfully, that the vast majority
of kids are really doing a good job with their lives, that is so at variance
with the story we've been told that people don't believe it. How do you move
us from the story we are currently being told and, therefore, telling, to a
more realistic story that will give people more of a sense of hope and
empowerment |